5 Reasons Why You Don’t Qualify for a Mortgage

Kelly Hudson • February 13, 2019

It’s not just because of finances


As a mortgage broker I receive calls from people who want to know how to qualify for a mortgage.   Most of the time it comes down to finances but there are other reasons as well.

Here are the 5 most common reasons why your home mortgage loan application could be denied :  

1.  Too Much Debt

When home buyers seek a mortgage, the words “debt-to-income ratio” quickly enters into the vocabulary, and it’s not without reason. Too much debt is a red flag to lenders, signifying you may not be able to handle credit responsibly.

Lenders will analyze how much debt you carry and what percentage of your income it takes to pay your debt. Debt ration is just as important as your credit score and payment history.

Two affordability ratios you need to be aware of:

  • Rule #1 – GROSS DEBT SERVICE (GDS) Your monthly housing costs are generally not supposed to exceed 32% of your gross monthly income.   
  • Rule #2 – TOTAL DEBT SERVICE (TDS) Your entire monthly debt payments should not exceed 42% of your gross monthly income.

If you don’t have a good debt to income ratio, don’t give up hope. You have options available including lowering your current debt levels and working with your Mortgage Broker.  

2. Poor Credit History

Some people don’t realize if they are late on their credit card/loan/mortgage payments the lender sends that information to the credit bureaus.

  • Late/non payments on your credit report will make your score drop like a rock
  • Exceeding your credit card limit, applying for more credit cards/loans will lower your score.
  • Bankruptcy or Consumer Proposal will significantly impact your score, and stay on your credit report for up to 7 years.

Your credit history is a great way for a lender to tell whether you’re a risky investment or not. Lenders look not only at your minimum credit score, but also at whether you have a significant amount of late payments on your credit report.

Your Mortgage Broker will run your credit bureau to see if there are any challenges you need to be aware of. Check out Solving the Puzzle – 5 factors used in determining your Credit Score    

3. Insufficient Income and Assets

With the high price of homes in the Vancouver & Toronto area, sometimes people simply don’t earn enough money to afford: mortgage payments, property taxes and strata fees along with their existing debt (credit cards, loans, lines of credit etc.).

You need to prove your previous 2 years’ income on your taxes with your Notice of Assessments (NOA). This is the summary form that the Federal Government sends back to you after you file your taxes, showing how much you filed for income and if you either owe money or received a refund. 

If you can’t provide documentation to prove your income, then you will likely get denied for a home mortgage loan.

Some home buyers will need to provide more money for a down payment (perhaps a gift from their family) or try to purchase a home with suite income. In some cases, home buyers will need to add someone else on title of the home, in order to add their income to the mortgage application.  

4. Down Payment is Too Small

A lender looks at the down payment as how much of an investment a buyer will be putting in their future home. Therefore, bigger is always better when it comes a down payment to satisfy your home mortgage loan application. Start saving now.

To qualify for a mortgage in Canada the minimum down payment is 5% for the purchase of an owner-occupied home & 20% for a rental property.

In Canada if you have less than 20% down payment, the federal government dictates that the home buyer must purchase CMHC Mortgage Default Insurance which is calculated as a percentage of the loan and is based on the size of your down payment. The more you borrow the higher percentage you will pay in insurance premiums. Check out Everything You Wanted to Know about Mortgage Default Insurance

For those with less than 20% down payment, the maximum amortization is 25 years, with more than 20% down payment 30-35 years (depending on the lender).  Check out 5 GREAT Reasons To Provide a 20% Down Payment when Buying a Home

5. Inadequate Employment History

Most lenders will want to see a consistent employment history of 2 years when applying for a mortgage, because they want to know you’re able to hold down a job long enough to pay back the money they’ve loaned you.

To prove your employment, you will need to prove a Job Letter with salary details.

If you’ve been denied a mortgage, chances are it was because of one of the above five reasons. Don’t be deterred, with a little patience and some work on your end, you can put yourself in a position to get approved the next time you apply.

The chart below lists the 10 main reasons people either don’t want or can’t get a mortgage.

Mortgages are complicated… BUT they don’t have to be!  Engage an expert.

Give me a call and let’s discuss a mortgage that works for you (not the bank)!

Kelly Hudson

Mortgage Expert

Mortgage Architects

Mobile 604-312-5009  

Kelly@KellyHudsonMortgages.com

www.KellyHudsonMortgages.com

Kelly Hudson
MORTGAGE ARCHITECTS
RECENT POSTS 

By Kelly Hudson April 3, 2025
Are you debating whether it's smarter to rent or buy a home in Canada? It's a common question, and the answer depends on your personal situation. Both renting and buying have their pros and cons, but for most people, homeownership tends to offer substantial long-term benefits. Let’s explore both options clearly, so you can confidently decide what’s best for you. Advantages of Buying a Home 1. Personal Freedom and Customization Owning your home means having the freedom to personalize your living space. Dreaming of a bold paint colour or unique flooring? Go ahead—your home, your rules! 2. Building Equity and Wealth Each mortgage payment you make is an investment in yourself. Over time, your home typically appreciates in value, increasing your equity. This can become a significant asset that helps secure your financial future. 3. Stability and Security Owning offers peace of mind. You don’t need to worry about sudden rent hikes or eviction notices. Your home remains yours until you decide otherwise. 4. Long-Term Financial Benefits Homeownership acts as forced savings. Unlike renting, every mortgage payment moves you closer to outright ownership, building a financial foundation that can support you and your family for years to come. Challenges of Buying a Home 1. Upfront Costs Buying comes with significant initial costs, including a down payment, legal fees, home inspection, appraisal, moving expenses, etc. 2. Responsibility for Maintenance Owning a home means you're responsible for maintenance and repairs. This can sometimes be costly and inconvenient. 3. Reduced Flexibility Selling a home typically takes time, which can limit your flexibility if you need or want to relocate quickly. Advantages of Renting 1. Easy Mobility Renting offers flexibility to relocate easily, beneficial for frequent job changes or lifestyle adjustments. 2. Fewer Responsibilities Repairs and maintenance are generally your landlord’s responsibility, reducing stress and unexpected expenses. 3. Lower Initial Costs Renting typically requires just a security deposit and the first month's rent, making it easier financially at the start. Downsides of Renting  1. No Equity Building Rent payments do not contribute to your equity. Instead, you’re effectively paying your landlord’s mortgage, offering no long-term financial return. 2. Restrictions and Rules Landlords often impose limitations, such as no pets or restrictions on decorating, making it challenging to feel fully at home. 3. Instability and Uncertainty Renters may face sudden rent increases or eviction if the landlord decides to sell or repurpose the property, disrupting your life significantly.
By Kelly Hudson March 17, 2025
Since March 2022, mortgage rates in Canada have risen significantly, raising concerns for homeowners and potential buyers. But what drives these changes, and how do they impact your choice between fixed and variable mortgage rates? Let's simplify this important financial topic.